ICAI Peer Review Process: Eligibility, Form 1 Filing and Online Application Guide

The ICAI Peer Review Process is an important quality assurance mechanism introduced by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) to enhance the quality of professional services provided by practising Chartered Accountants. This comprehensive guide explains everything you need to know about Peer Review, including eligibility criteria, Form 1 filing, documentation requirements, and the online application process.

14 November, 2026

If you are a practising Chartered Accountant, peer review is no longer something you can keep postponing. Many statutory audits cannot even be accepted today unless the firm already holds a valid Peer Review Certificate.

But the moment a firm starts the process, the same doubts come up. Are we even covered? Who files Form 1? Is it still done by email? How long does the whole thing take?

This guide explains the ICAI peer review process in simple language, along with the latest changes you should know about.

What is Peer Review in Simple Words?

Peer review is a quality check of your audit and assurance work, done by another experienced Chartered Accountant.

It is not an investigation into your clients. The reviewer does not sit and question whether your client's profit was correctly computed. He checks whether you followed the process properly. Were the Standards on Auditing complied with? Was the work documented? Were independence and quality control policies actually in place?

In short, peer review looks at how you audit, not at what your client did.

The firm being reviewed is called a Practice Unit, or PU. It can be a CA practising in their own name, a proprietorship, a partnership firm or an LLP.

Who Needs a Peer Review Certificate?

ICAI made peer review mandatory in four phases. Here is the broad picture:

PhaseWho is coveredMandatory from
Phase IFirms auditing entities whose equity or debt is listed, as defined under SEBI LODR1 April 2022
Phase IIFirms auditing specified large unlisted public companies, or firms rendering attestation services with 5 or more partners1 July 2024
Phase IIIFirms auditing entities that raised over Rs 50 crore from public, banks or financial institutions, or public interest entities, or firms rendering attestation services with 4 or more partners1 July 2025 (after deferment)
Phase IVFirms auditing branches of Public Sector Banks, or firms rendering attestation services with 3 or more partners31 December 2026
Two practical points most members miss:
  • The partner count is checked on the date the phase becomes applicable and on every date after that. A firm that adds its third partner in 2027 is covered from that day.
  • The certificate must be valid both when you accept the statutory audit and when you sign the report. If you accepted an audit before your phase became applicable, you still need a valid certificate on the day you sign.
Example: A four partner firm that only files returns and handles GST compliance is not caught by the partner test, because it signs no audit. The day it accepts an audit required by law, it needs the certificate first. ICAI defines statutory audit as any audit mandated by law, so do not assume tax audit falls outside it. And once Phase IV applies, any firm planning a PSB branch audit, even a proprietorship, needs the certificate before accepting the assignment.

Phase IV: The Date Every Mid Size Firm Should Note

Phase IV was originally meant to apply from 1 April 2025. It was shifted to 1 January 2026, and ICAI has now extended it further to 31 December 2026.

This is the phase that touches the largest number of ordinary practising firms, for two reasons. Three partners is a very common firm structure in India, and Public Sector Bank branch audit is bread and butter work for small and mid size firms.

So if your firm has three or more partners and you sign statutory audits, treat this as your real deadline and apply early. The process itself is not long, but reviewer availability and cleaning up old documentation always take more time than expected.

Eligibility to Become a Peer Reviewer

Many members want to sit on the other side of the table. Under the Peer Review Guidelines, 2022, you are eligible to be enrolled as a Peer Reviewer if:

  • You are a member in practice with at least seven years of assurance practice experience, or
  • You were in employment, later obtained a Certificate of Practice, have at least ten years of employment experience along with at least three years of audit experience in practice, and are in whole time practice at the time of enrolment
You also need to:
  • Apply for empanelment in Form 3
  • Clear the peer reviewer test prescribed by the Board
  • Submit a declaration of confidentiality
  • Undergo the prescribed training
One important restriction to remember. A Peer Reviewer cannot accept any professional assignment from the Practice Unit he reviews for two years from the date of appointment. So peer review is not a client acquisition route, and it was never meant to be one.

Form 1: The Heart of the Application

Form 1 is the Application cum Questionnaire filed by the Practice Unit. This is where the entire process begins.

What goes into it:

  • Firm details as per ICAI records, FRN and membership numbers
  • The peer review period, which means the three financial years preceding the year of application
  • A list of all assurance services signed during that period
  • Answers to a detailed questionnaire covering quality control policies, independence, documentation and staff training
Form 1 is not a formality. Your own answers decide what the reviewer will look for during the visit. If you state that you have a written independence policy, be ready to place it on the table.

The other forms in the cycle, in short:

  • Form 2: Reviewer's acceptance and confidentiality declaration
  • Form 3: Reviewer's empanelment application
  • Form 5: Reviewer's notice of visit along with the sample selected
  • Form 6: Reviewer seeking additional information from the PU
  • Form 7: Joint request by PU and Reviewer for extra time
  • Form 8: Request to extend validity of the certificate
  • Form 9: Reviewer submitting the report to the Board

 Online Application: The New PRB Web Portal

This is the biggest recent change, and a lot of members are still unaware of it.

ICAI has launched a dedicated Peer Review Board web portal, and with effect from 2 July 2026, all new Form 1 applications are processed exclusively through it. The portal is available at prb.icai.org.

Earlier, Form 1 used to travel by email and firms had almost no visibility on where the application stood or when the three reviewer names would come back. The portal now covers the full lifecycle in one place: application submission, reviewer allotment, report filing and generation of the Peer Review Certificate.

So if someone still tells you to email Form 1 to the Board, that advice is outdated. Log in and file it online.

The Process and the 20 Working Day Timeline

Under the 2022 Guidelines, the entire review, including submission of the reviewer's report to the Board, is to be completed within 20 working days from the date the Board receives your Form 1. Earlier this window was 45 days. For a New Unit (a firm less than 12 months old, or one not yet doing assurance work), the window is just 7 working days.

The broad flow:

  1. PU files Form 1
  2. Board shares a panel of three reviewers along with the fee working
  3. PU selects one reviewer from that panel
  4. Reviewer submits Form 2, then sends the proposed visit date and selected sample in Form 5
  5. On site review is conducted, and it should not extend beyond six working days
  6. Preliminary report is issued where needed, and the PU submits its representation
  7. Reviewer submits the final report to the Board
  8. On a clean report, the Board issues the Peer Review Certificate
If the timeline slips, the PU and the Reviewer jointly intimate the Board in Form 7.

Validity, Sample Size and Fees

  • A Peer Review Certificate is normally valid for three years, counted from the date the Board receives the peer review report
  • The number of engagements the reviewer must check depends on your firm's age and its receipts from assurance clients. If you have fewer engagements than the minimum sample, the reviewer checks all of them and the certificate may be issued for a shorter period, typically 18 months
  • The Board prescribes a minimum fee based on your average receipts from assurance services during the review period, and shares the fee working along with the reviewer panel. The fee is payable to the Reviewer within seven days of receiving the invoice
  • Mistakes Practice Units Keep Repeating

  • Applying one month before you need the certificate. Reviewer allotment, visit scheduling and report acceptance all take time
  • Weak documentation. Engagement letters, independence declarations, audit programmes and working papers must actually exist for the review period. They cannot be created on the day of the visit
  • Over claiming in Form 1. Write what you do, not what sounds good
  • Forgetting renewal. The new certificate starts the day after the old one ends only if the Board receives your reviewer's report before the old one expires. Apply at least six months ahead so there is no gap in which you cannot sign
Documentation is where most observations come from, and it is also the one thing fully in your control. If your team is still building audit files from memory rather than from a standard set of working papers, the Statutory Audit Masterclass by CA Tushar Makkar covers how a proper audit file is built, from engagement letter to reporting.

Related Searches

How to Maintain Audit Documentation | Statutory Audit Checklist Practical Guide for CAs

Final Thoughts

Peer review is not a punishment. It is a basic test of whether your audit file can stand on its own without you sitting next to it and explaining things.Firms that take it seriously usually come out with better templates, cleaner files and far fewer observations in the next cycle. Firms that treat it as paperwork struggle every single time.If Phase IV covers your firm, the work starts now, not in December.

FAQs

1. Is Peer Review mandatory for all Chartered Accountant firms in India?

No. ICAI has introduced mandatory Peer Review in four phases based on the type of audit assignments and the number of partners in a firm. The applicability dates range from 1 April 2022 to 31 December 2026. Firms should check the applicable phase to determine their requirements.

2. What is Form 1 in the ICAI Peer Review Process?

Form 1 is the Application cum Questionnaire submitted by the Practice Unit (PU). It includes firm details, FRN, membership numbers, details of assurance services performed during the preceding three financial years, and information about the firm's quality control policies.

3. How can a CA firm apply for Peer Review online?

CA firms can submit Form 1 through the ICAI Peer Review Board's dedicated online portal at https://prb.icai.org. With effect from 2 July 2026, all new Form 1 applications must be submitted exclusively through this portal.

4. How long does the ICAI Peer Review Process take, and what is the certificate validity?

Under the Peer Review Guidelines, 2022, the review process, including submission of the reviewer's report, is generally required to be completed within 20 working days from the date the Board receives Form 1. A Peer Review Certificate is normally valid for three years, subject to applicable conditions.

CA Tushar Makkar
Author - Auditing in real life | Consulting in India, US, Europe and Middle East | Content creator | Ex-PwC | CA AIR 47 Nov' 17 | YouTuber 60k+ | Expertise in manage accounts and Audit.

Bridging Textbooks & Corporate Worlds |Exclusive Special offer | ENROLL NOW